Abe & Me
When I was in preschool, I had a best friend with a big upstairs hallway in her house. At night, we would turn off all the lights, have her older brother (good arm) throw a penny down said hallway, and then get on our hands and knees hoping to be the first to find it. Surprise tickle attacks and rugburn were constant risks, but I remember those games as the highlight of the sleepover.
I would like to play this game again. I wonder if I would still enjoy it as much. I predict: yes, I would.